Crate Training for Puppies and Dogs
Wondering how to begin crate training your puppy or dog, or even whether you should? This page will tell you.
Crate training gets a dog so used to being closed into a crate that he or she can safely be left in it for a few hours at a time. It can greatly speed up the process of potty training a puppy or dog.
The method has its pros and cons. If it works for your dog, it gives both you and the dog a wonderful flexibility in many situations. But if it isn’t right for your dog, there are good alternatives to crate training.
On this page, I offer pros and cons, a basic method for crate training, some tips on making it work, and some alternatives.
Crate Training: PRO
Crate training helps tremendously in potty training puppies and adult dogs. (link to my page on doing that)
Your dog can be confined when it is necessary, without undue stress on the dog or serious wear and tear on your home.
If your dog ever has to be left at a veterinarian’s office, travel on an airplane, or be evacuated from your home, being in a crate then will be far less stressful if he is already crate-trained.
It’s a nice way to include a puppy in what is going on without your having to tend him constantly, for example, if you are giving a party.
Many dogs will seek out their crates to relax in.
Crate Training: CON
- It may take some time to get your dog accustomed to being left in the dog crate, and you will need another way to confine him so you don’t push the crate training too fast.
- Some people might leave their dogs in the crates too much. How much is too much? It depends on the dog and situation.
- Crate training isn’t suitable for some dogs. For example, a dog who has spent a lot of time in crates or cages (in a shelter or at a previous owner’s) may become very upset. You may or may not be able to overcome this with patient training.
- Dogs with separation anxiety may become more upset in a crate than in a larger space.
- A strong, frantic dog can get out of most crates, perhaps hurting himself in the process.
- Some people just hate the idea of confining their dogs this way. Learning more about crate training often overcomes this dislike, but if you find that it doesn’t for you, then use alternatives to crates.
A Basic Crate Training Method
First, of course, you need a crate..If you need to get one, take a look at this very popular one: MidWest Life Stages Double-Door Folding Metal Dog Crate, 42 Inches by 28 Inches by 31 Inches It comes in several sizes.
Select a good location for the crate — or more than one location. In your bedroom is good at night, but while you are home during the day, it’s best to have the crate near where people will be. Either move the crate around, or some people even have two crates. Don’t put the crate where sunlight coming in from a window will make the air hot for the dog or force him to be in the sun.
Tie the door open, or even take it off at first. Let the dog notice the crate and examine it if he wishes.
Bit by bit, make it more interesting. Throw toys or treats in. Talk lovingly to him if he goes in. Pet him while he is in the crate.
Begin feeding the dog in the crate. When he is comfortable going in (and this can be anything from an hour to much longer), then begin closing the door for very short periods of time while you are right there.
If he whines to get out, don’t let him out and don’t sweet-talk him until there is a moment when he isn’t whining. Just wait till he is quiet. Then you can let him out. If you let him out while he is whining, you are teaching him that whining works with you.
With each of the steps, pay attention to what the dog indicates about his feelings. Crate training is most effective when it isn’t rushed. If he is uncomfortable at a particular step, back up to a previous one.
Once he accepts the door closed while you are there, begin going elsewhere in your home and gradually lengthening the time you are gone. Having toys in the crate is useful here.
Then leave the house for 5 minutes and come back, working up to leaving for longer times.
Close the dog in at bedtime and let him out first thing in the morning. But once the dog behaves without being locked in at night, leave the door open or remove it from the crate (unless you are using it during the day sometimes) and keep it nearby. If you are housetraining a young puppy, you will probably be going outside with him in the middle of the night for a while.
Here’s a page on how to choose a dog crate and a dog bed for it. And do check out that crate I mentioned, at Amazon.
Crate Training Tips
Never put the dog into the crate as punishment. You want the dog to think of it in a happy way.
You have to go back to work and your new puppy or dog still isn’t completely crate-trained or reliable when loose in the house. What to do? Create an alternative space for a while (see below), or crate the dog and ask a friend or neighbor to come by several times during the day, either as a favor or for pay, to let the dog out for a while. Or hire a pet sitter. Or take the puppy to a good doggy day care.
Be sure to leave some toys or treats with the dog. I’ve done a page on the Kong, a bouncy rubber dog toy that you can fill with dog treats, peanut butter, cheese, etc., to occupy your dog for a good long time. (It’s excellent for occupying an uncrated dog too.)
If a dog is tired out, he will accept the crate more willingly. That means exercise! Many dog behavior problems are resolved with exercise.
You may have read that crate-training is “natural” because dogs are descended from wolves, who live in dens. While there is a grain of truth in that, a crate is also an artificial confinement device which many people use mainly for their own convenience. So use it as little as possible with the door closed!
Keep an eye on the crate for signs that the dog became frustrated and tried to get out.
You can combine clicker training with crate training. Click when the dog goes in, then give a treat.
We have crate-trained every puppy we’ve had. It was particularly useful with Sunbeam, our Basenji, who was a terror for months. One time she was loose and somehow managed to drag a bag of white flour off the kitchen counter and distribute its contents all over the living room. At least that vacuumed up easily! I became more diligent about using the crate with her after that.
Alternatives to Crate Training
- Use an exercise pen, also called an ex pen or x pen.
- Create a dog-safe part of your home.
- Create a dog-safe area outside.
1. Exercise pens:
Exercise pens (commonly called ex-pens) are sturdy wire enclosures that don’t typically have floors. Most don’t come with ceilings, but some do. They can provide a larger space for your dog than a crate does.
They can be tipped over, and without a floor they provide no housebreaking protection. A dog prone to jumping or climbing might get out — so know your dog before using one. They come in heights of 18 inches to four feet, and can be used indoors and outdoors. They fold flat for storage.
A friend gave us an ex-pen just before Kelly and I took off to live and work full-time in a large motorhome for a few years. At the time, Sunbeam, our lively Basenji was about a year and a half, and Teddy Bear, our Australian Shepherd was about 11. I was surprised at how much the dogs enjoyed being in the pen when we stopped at campgrounds — they loved the attention they got from other campers walking past. And the fact that Sunbeam never escaped from it speaks very well for ex-pens! I also used it as a clothesline. Still have it after all those years!
Here is a best-selling ex pen. In this illustration it’s being used with a crate. You can choose your size on the page at Amazon.
2. Create a dog-safe part of your home
“Dog-safe” depends on whether or not your dog is potty trained yet. Often people confine their dogs in bathrooms, but if you do, be sure there aren’t chemicals or other things the dog might accidentally get into. (What’s under the sink? You can buy latches with clips on them at hardware stores.) You can use an exercise pen, or a baby gate, to divide this part of your house from the rest and still be able to see and hear the dog.
If you are still potty training the dog, as a rule of thumb he will be more inclined to hold it in a quite small space, like a crate.
Some people have made dog areas in the bottom of a closet. (You would take off the door and use a gate instead… or cut a hole in the door.) Just be sure to remove all your shoes! And be sure your dog likes it.
3. Create a dog-safe area outside
If you have a securely fenced yard, terrific! You may want to add a dog door so your dog can come and go — to the whole house or a selected part.
Otherwise, you can get a kennel or an outside playpen for your dog. Be sure that your dog always has shade and protection from rain, etc., as well as drinking water.
Also be sure that his barking isn’t tormenting your neighbors. Ask people who live near you to let you know if he does bark much.
It may not be safe to leave your dog outside by himself, whether in a fenced yard, a kennel, ex-pen, or whatever. Besides unsupervised children passing by, in some areas there are risks of theft. If you have any doubts, talk to others in your community, and be cautious.
Crate Training Dogs: Well Worth the Trouble!
If everyone did crate training, there would be far fewer dogs in shelters because they never quite got potty trained or they were too destructive.
Sure, it’s only a dream to think that everyone would do it, but I do hope you will seriously consider crate training!
If you don’t have a crate now, take a look at my page on choosing dog crates… And get that puppy crate trained!
Sorry I didn’t get to this for months! If you haven’t solved it yet, find a good trainer.
My son has a Pyrenees/ husky puppy that is 16 weeks old along with a 8 year old dog. Both r fine together. The puppy poops outside but then comes in later and poops. I was there and I could not understand why. By 10 pm both went out again. By 2 am there are 3 piles on floor with pee. So frustrating. If crated he pees and poops in there
I think you are right that if she were loose she might be in bed with you. What we did one time when we had a situation a bit like this was that we had her crate right next to my side of the bed, where I could groggily reach in and pet her when she fussed but had been outside recently enough that I didn’t think she needed another trip out yet. Maybe something like that would work for you. It did make it awkward if I had to pee in the night! But it didn’t last more than a week or two.
A favorite toy in the crate might help too.
She is trying to train you! This is about where she wants to be, due to the previous setup, as well as about when she needs to go potty. Be patient and best wishes!
Hi, we just adopted a four month old puppy and don’t know much about her background. We’re trying to avoid having her in our bed with us so we put a small crate in our bedroom but she cries on and off all night, the previous owner did say she slept in the bed with them,…do you have any advice about how to make her feel less stressed in the crate? So far she seems to do ok in the crate in the kitchen for a few hours at a time but,since she’s not fully potty trained yet we can’t let her stay out at night yet. Plus Isuspect if she were out at night she would just keep jumping on the bed. Any ideas?
Hi Claire — The first thing I would do would be take her to your veterinarian and discuss the situation fully. If nothing came from that, or before you have a chance to do that, I would set an alarm for about halfway into the night and take her out then. If she had already peed or pooped at that point, Iwould set the alarm for even earlier. Not the greatest for your sleep but she’s got a habit going now and you’ll need to somehow change it. Best wishes!
We have always crate trained our dogs, my other two dogs were a dream. My newest dog however is a complete nightmare. She is perfectly house trained when I’m at home however at nearly 12 months old she is still unable to go through the night without fouling in the crate – we even hang around outside before going to bed to make sure she relieves herself but this appears to make no difference. Really at our wits end ?.
Judie, If he has developed this habit in your house since about a year and a half ago, then it’s going to be strongly ingrained. I would suggest that you have a thorough veterinary exam in case there is a physical reason that could be addressed. (By the way, it would be a crate inside an x-pen, not the other way around.) I would also go to google and search for chihuahua forums and dog forums. If you go to general dog forums, look for ones with chihuahua sections. Find an active forum where people are posting, and ask your question… you could just cut and paste it from what you asked here. Chihuahua owners will have breed-specific opinions. Beyond that, you could consider taking him to a dog day care place in Las Vegas when you are at work. Finally, if your quality of life and his are too compromised, consider limiting the parts of your house he is ever allowed in. The last resort would be to give him away, but I believe you can make it work one way or another. Best wishes!
I rescued an older male chihuahua, neutered already, about a year and a half ago. He quickly blended in with my other two dogs and the car. He’s really sweet and we love him, but he marks throughout the house – never in just one or two spots. Belly bands haven’t worked. Cleaning w/enzyme sprays hasn’t worked. Now I’ve gone back to work full time and I need for this to stop. He never poops or full pees inside, just marks. I’m thinking of getting him a very large crate and adding pee-pee pads, or your idea of crate with ex-pen inside. We live in Las Vegas so having him outdoors all day isn’t an option. Any other suggestions ?
Very helpful tips:) You need also a lot of patience:)
Be sure to take him out just before you go to bed and you could try keeping him out of the kitchen at night, though of course that could result in an accident elsewhere! Also, read this post of mine: http://www.training-dogs.com/48/when-crate-training-isnt-working/
i have no crate,but the dog doesn’t go in the house at all during the day,only sometime in the night when i am sleeping and then only in the kitchen. i can’t understand why? the dog was given to me and i don’t know the age,except he is full grown.what are any alternatives?